Matthew 24:36-44 A Future With Hope [or Enough With the Rapture Already]
December 1, 2013 – Caitlin Trussell
Augustana Lutheran Church, Denver, CO
“But about that day and hour no one knows, neither the angels of heaven, nor the Son, but only the Father. For as the days of Noah were, so will be the coming of the Son of Man. For as in those days before the flood they were eating and drinking, marrying and giving in marriage, until the day Noah entered the ark, and they knew nothing until the flood came and swept them all away, so too will be the coming of the Son of Man. Then two will be in the field; one will be taken and one will be left. Two women will be grinding meal together; one will be taken and one will be left. Keep awake therefore, for you do not know on what day your Lord is coming. But understand this: if the owner of the house had known in what part of the night the thief was coming, he would have stayed awake and would not have let his house be broken into.Therefore you also must be ready, for the Son of Man is coming at an unexpected hour.
For one long summer, I was a day-camp counselor. Not the super-fun-guitar-strumming kind – just kick that little bit of counselor stereotype right on outta here. Oh no, I was the 17-year-old-in-charge-of-a-large-group-of-5-year-old-girls kind of counselor. I was more the protector-against-mortal-peril kind of counselor – think mother hen. Our location was cool but slightly tricky for herding 12 little girls. It was a dried out river arroyo near Pasadena, California. Water hadn’t run through it in eons and it was full of scrub oak and draught-resistant trees and the constant threat of poison oak. We built a group fort and created a group flag which means that there was fort raiding and flag stealing going on. It was utter triumph to show up at the end of the day flag ceremony with another group’s flag – a sign of a successful raid.
Victory and shame were the two-sides of that stolen flag event. The ultimate in victory was to show up at the flag ceremony with another groups’ kid – but for the counselor with the missing kid, it was the ultimate shame. Any of you want to guess who one of those shamed camp counselors was at the end of the day? Yup, yours truly. Oh, the ultimate shame…knowing your kid was taken and knowing the return would be anything but a triumph. After all, even in this fairly innocent form, being taken was not a good thing…
Being taken is rarely a good thing. In fact, our gospel writer seems to have a strong bias against being taken, a problem so big that no one would ever knowingly opt into it. Revisiting the flood story reveals this negative bias. The people swept away in the flood story, the ones not on the ark, were leading their normal lives until they suddenly were not. Through the story of those lost in the flood, the gospel writer is setting up the negative lens of being taken.
The negative lens of being taken is the set up to read the next verses. There are two workers in the field, one taken the other not; and the two women grinding meal together, one taken and one left. Through the lens of the flood story, being taken out of the field or away from the grinding are big problems in this text. And of course that’s problematic! Who would want to be living life in one moment and only to be taken out of it the next?!
In the context of the gospel of Matthew, being taken is a bad deal. At the time of its writing, chaos was in full force. The Roman occupation left the Jewish Temple in Jerusalem destroyed, there were wars and rumors of wars, and many people were suddenly being taken away, kidnapped either to be killed or enslaved. In this text being taken is a bad deal. For people curious about or hurt by rapture theology, this begs a critical question?  If being taken is a bad deal, might the gospel be suggesting that being left behind is the better deal?
For some of us long told otherwise about being left behind, just asking this question of scripture can be good news indeed. And, for some of us, it may be the only good news needed today. However, in the interest of full disclosure on the Bible text today, there’s more…you just have to wait for it – which is appropriate because Advent is a time of waiting.
As Advent begins, the first Sunday is filled with the image of actively waiting and keeping watch. This scripture argues for watchfulness in the midst of life being lived. Notice that the list of activities of those washed away in the flood were simply normal activities, not tied to judgment – “they were eating and drinking, marrying and giving in marriage.” The workers in the field and the women grinding meal are doing the work of daily living. So, by their example, we are also encouraged to be living and working and taking care of the things of daily life even, and maybe especially, in the midst of the chaos of the times.
This is part of the reassurance of this text. There is a lot that cannot be controlled. But there is still life to live. And into the chaos, the wars, the kidnappings, and just as equally into the work, the life, the events of the day, comes the Son of Man. The Son of Man is also called “the Son” as well as “Lord” in these verses. All of these labels mean Jesus. Jesus is the Son; Jesus is Lord; and Jesus is the Son of Man. It’s important to spell this out because there seems to be a temptation to disconnect the Son of Man in this passage in Matthew from the Jesus revealed in the gospels as a whole. As if somehow Jesus lived, loved, healed, and died, and then resurrected in a seriously bad mood ready to wield some divine wrath upon a fallen humanity.
It is not so difficult to fathom how idea of the Son of Man became disconnected from the Jesus who died on the cross. It is the same disconnect made by the criminal on the cross from our gospel reading last week, hanging next to Jesus who was also on a cross and challenging him to save them both if he was the actually Messiah. Regardless, the one who hung on the cross is also called the Son of Man. And this is a word of comfort and hope to Jesus followers during the confusing times of the first century and the equally if not more confusing times of the 21st century.
Because, as Pastor Pederson reminded us yesterday at Nina Forgo’s memorial service, Christian people model life not on one particular morality or philosophy or piety. In relation to this text today, I would add that Christian people do not model life on panic or fear either.
Rather, Christian people’s lives hinge on promise, God’s promise.
God’s promise that insists there is more to the human story and God’s own story than that which has been experienced already.
God’s promise that the Son of Man, for whom we wait and stay watchful this Advent, is the Christ who walked the earth as healer of those in need and died on a cross for all.
God’s promise that draws us into the fullness of the future, a future with hope.
 Barbara R. Rossing. The Rapture Exposed: The Message of Hope in the Book of Revelation. (New York: Basic Books, 2004), 178-181.
 Ibid. Rapture theology is a 19th century construct.
 Arland Hultgren. Commentary on Matthew 24:36-44 on WorkingPreacher.com. [http://www.workingpreacher.org/preaching.aspx?commentary_id=1912
 Jeremiah 29:11 – For surely I know the plans I have for you, says the Lord, plans for your welfare and not for harm, to give you a future with hope.